So, what IS autism, anyway?
Not a rhetorical question, that.
I suppose that on some philosophical level, there is a knowable "something" that is the quintessence of that which we call "autism."
Problem is, we haven't managed to catch up to it yet, either from a causality standpoint or a definitional standpoint.
When I first began to learn about autism, I took a line of thought that I think I've since outgrown... I hung my hat on the clinical, psychiatric definition of autism that formed the basis for Joy's diagnosis. That definition comes from the
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, published by the American Psychiatric Association. The most recent edition, the 4th edition, came out in 1994, and is known as the DSM-IV. I referenced in a
previous post the peculiar combination-platter approach that checks off certain criteria in certain groupings to constitute an autism diagnosis:
A total of six (or more) items from (1), (2), and (3), with at least two from (1), and one each from (2) and (3)
Uncle Schnirelmann obligingly contributed to the comments of that post a calculation of the number of potential combinations!
Here's the thing, though. This particular combination-platter that "is" autism has only been on the books since 1994. Autism was first added to the DSM in 1980; PDD-NOS (which broadens the autism spectrum considerably) was added in 1987; the autism definition expanded yet further in the current 1994 version, including the first mention of Asperger's.
Is autism in-and-of-itself really only the latest psychiatric definition? Did autism
an sich (German for in-and-of-itself) actually change? Surely a reference book doesn't have quite that kind of power, right?
For anyone still hanging his or her hat on the clinical definition, hold on to the brim, because the world of psychiatrically-defined autism will be changing again, in not too many years.
The new DSM-V is due out in May 2012. The American Psychiatric Association started the wheels of the new edition turning as far back as 1999, in collaboration with the National Institute of Mental Health. There have been conferences and task forces, and starting in May 2008, 13 different work groups were convened to deal with different areas in the purview of the DSM. Autism is covered by the Neurodevelopmental Disorders Work Group, chaired by Susan Swedo, MD.
I didn't know all this off the top of my head, of course; got it from the
American Psychiatric Association web site on the upcoming DSM-V. I started poking into this due to a blog post called
Sausages and Legislation by afbh at
Whose Planet Is It Anyway? The post references an
LA Times piece from earlier this week, regarding a dispute between psychiatrists as to whether the process of assembling the DSM-V is going to be primarily a transparent process, or a closed-door process.
So that got me wondering, what exactly do we know about the status of the autism definition revision at this point? And that led me to this brief
Report of the DSM-V Neurodevelopmental Disorders Work Group, dated November 2008.
The report lists three main areas of discussion for the work group:
1) Possible modification of ADHD criteria to allow for co-morbidity of autism and ADHD (currently excluded). The ADHD & Disruptive Behavior Disorders Work Group has agreed to consider this possibility.
2) Discussion of the validity of Rett’s disorder as a separate disorder and inclusion of a new modifier within the Autism Spectrum Disorders (ASD), which might include genetic and medical disorders and other biologically-definable conditions.
3) How to address Pervasive Developmental Disorders – Not Otherwise Specified (PDD-NOS). The individuals currently diagnosed with PDD-NOS may still be described in DSM-V, but the work group will discuss whether they can redefine ASD in such a way that the PDD-NOS diagnosis isn’t necessary, as this diagnosis currently captures a very heterogeneous group of individuals.
Then there are eight additional questions, and various subcommittees. I'm hoping this gets wider play in the autism blogs --
Kristina at Autism Vox has started that ball rolling. I'd like to see someone eventually take it in turn to invite discussions of each of the points and questions separately. (Not to worry. I won't inflict that on my particular readership!)
I will just comment a bit, though, on the one of the first three points that jumped out at me, and that's point #2, about the interface between autism and other genetic or biologically-definable conditions. The dual-diagnosis thing has been of particular interest to me, given Joy's combination of autism with linear nevus sebaceous syndrome. In our case, we've been conceptualizing Joy's autism as falling somehow under the LNSS umbrella. But I've also heard people referring to their quests to "rule out" autism by testing for genetic known-factors like Fragile X, and I've wondered why it couldn't be both -- especially since there's only one lone genetic exclusion in the DSM-IV, and that's
Rett syndrome.
It's always seemed strange to me that Rett should be singled out, and at least mildly concerning that if the list of exclusions were to grow explicitly, it could have a massive impact on the eligibility for autism services of people who also have Down Syndrome, or Fragile X, or LNSS, or whatever. The work group report implies, though, that there's discussion about taking it in the other direction, maybe with explicit inclusions?
Fascinating stuff. I'm hoping that the official discussion stays as transparent as possible.