I was reminded this weekend of a poem by Shel Silverstein, from the book
A Light in the Attic, about communication differences.

Here's the text if it's a little hard to read in the image:
Deaf DonaldDeaf Donald met Talkie Sue
But [signed:
I Love You] was all he could do.
And Sue said, "Donald, I sure do like you."
But [signed:
I Love You] was all he could do.
And Sue asked Donald, "Do you like me too?"
But [signed:
I Love You] was all he could do.
"Good-bye then, Donald, I’m leaving you."
But [signed:
I Love You] was all he did do.
And she left forever and she never knew
That [signed:
I Love You] means I love you.
Talkie Sue may have been a talker, but she surely wasn't much of a listener.
After reading the latest from Rhemashope over at
Autism in a Word (more on that later), I found myself trying to remember:
Did Joy ever say or echo anything resembling "I love you"?
It doesn't seem like something that one could possibly forget. But it's been SO long since we've heard those 80-some words that she used to speak, once upon a time. Among all the people who are working with her now, only Lynda at daycare and one of her school-district people have known her long enough to remember hearing her use words. Right now she has no spoken words at all, communicating via her photo cards when we ask her to, or her push-button when it's available, or the occasional "more" sign, but mostly just actions and glances and gestures.
I asked JoyDad, and he set me straight right away. "No, she never did." He had worked more deliberately than I to try to get an echo of "Love you!" back when there were more words floating about, and it just never came.
But here's what she DOES do:

When he goes to pick her up at daycare, she comes running up to him and gives him a great big hug, and sometimes even gives him a little pat-pat-pat on the back.
She gives kisses upon request, and sometimes initiates little puckery kissie-kissie motions.
And remember the
Popeye Sighting?
It's no wonder I got confused about how I heard, or didn't hear, the "I love you" a year and a half ago or more. I've been hearing it a lot lately, listening with all my heart. It just hasn't been verbal.
Rhemashope didn't need to hear the words spoken either, but I'm surely rejoicing with her about
what happened the other night at bedtime.
Someday. Someday.